May 11, 2009
No Greater Love
May 5, 2009
Jesus Camp Film Review
Jesus Camp Directed by Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady is supposed to give its more secular audience a window in the evangelical sub culture. According to the film makers the film takes you to:
"Becky Fischer's "Kids on Fire Summer Camp," where kids are taught to become dedicated Christian soldiers in God's army and are schooled in how to take back America for Christ. The film is a first-ever look into an intense training ground that recruits born-again Christian children to become an active part of America's political future."
The film starts with an address by President George W. Bush announcing his search for a candidate to replace Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, intermixed with radio commetary by Dr. James Dobson and others urging the church to awaken to the importance of the moment. The film proceeds to footage of a radio host, a bible believing Christian, who essentially takes issue with the tone and tenure of many present day evangelical leaders.
How are we supposed to even think about films like these?
J. Lee Grady editor of Charisma Magazine has this illuminating qoute "Jesus Camp is an uncanny introduction to life in the real world of charismatic faith, captured on film and introduced to an audience of mostly nonreligious Americans who had no idea until now that such people even existed."
Unfortunately, the nonreligious audience falls into the traps laid for them by the film writers.
The film has a clear political edge through the messaging of the flim makers and this is reflected in some of the more mainstream media reviews such as this one by Good Morning America. The commentary at one point, in a fairly straightforward mockery, says "instead of telling ghost stories around the camp fire, children, here, as young as 6, speak in tongues." What does the commentator think happens at pentecostal church camps? This is a central part of the groups religious teaching and its mockery is extremely unappropriate.
The film interposes Mike Papantonio who, along with being a radio host on Air America, is, according to the film makers is, a self-proclaimed mainline protestant and critic of the evangelical movement. In the interview, Mike admits that he does not believe that evangelicals should shape social norms.
The film is clearly meant to have your average viewer question the political and cultural relievance of evangelical Christianity. The film makers do a lot of slander to the evangelical pentecostal church, but raise a number of uncomfortable points for Christians and non-Christians who watch it.
If you have watched the film, a few important points of contention...
1) The documentary portrays the evangelical community as being fundamentally antiscience and at its base global warming deniers. This is a gross overstatement. While the evangelical community is more skeptical of some of the claims of global warming, it is soundly on the side of Godly stewardship of nature/creation. In fact some evangelical leaders are drawing attention to the moral dimensions of climate change.
2) The film makers use one particular scene to their particular advantage. At one point a cut out of the former President is brought in to be prayed over. This particular scene has been replayed in the media time and time again as the direct connection between politics and religion. While it's certainly uncommon to have a cut out many evangelicals pray for their leaders for all Christians are commanded to pray for their leaders no matter who they are. Pastor Fischer is clear that she would teach that all generations should pray for every leader. When asked by Katie Couric whether she would have the kids pray for President Clinton in the same manner, she says yes.
3) The death of Harry Potter. Many Christians believe that warlocks and conjuring up images of the devil is a severe evil. While many evangelicals do not have serious problems with the popular series, many remain weary of overt objects of evil.
4) The film has a scene from than Pastor Ted Haggard. Another unfortunate aftermath of Ted's own failings is that the film does have a few brief scenes with him. Though in the same movement its important to distinguish between the gross hipocracy and sin of Haggard's and the film itself. Ted had many idols in his life, especially politics and the need to be popular and adored, and its unfortunate that we see some of them on display in this film. As an aside to those non-Christian viewers, Ted never had the influence in the White House that he claimed.
5) There are a number of comments that Pastor Fischer makes in the film that makes it seem that Pastor Fischer's primary purpose was to raise some sort of political movement. Pastor Fischer's primary purpose is to minister to kids and its unfortunate that the film makers choose to twist the image of this woman.
The flim ends with the final vote for Justice Alito to the Supreme Court. It is clear from beginning to end that the film makers wanted to use this film as a political treatise against the evangelical community and because the flim makers choose the pentecostal subculture (that many Americans do not know about) the film is exhotic and twisted enough to carry the message and make it believable enough to many non-Christians that a woman whose primary purpose was to minister to children is actually hoping to defeat liberal politics and culture.
The controversy that the film created shut down the camp.
Becky Fisher in her own words.
Apr 30, 2009
Evangelicals Must Learn to Think Like a Minority?
Mr. Gage asserts that evangelicals must face our new political and culturally reality that we are a minority group. Gage points to the 2009 American Religious Identification Survey to show that Christians have shown identification decline for the last two decades.
The author makes a variety of disturbingly inaccurate statements but has at least a few points that are worth pondering. Mr. Gage argues that our thinking needs to shift. I would add with perhaps Mark Knoll author of the Scandal of the Evangelical Mind that rather our thinking needs to start.
Mr. Gage asserts that somehow the Evangelical notion of Winthrop "A City on the Hill" is really an implementation of Christian nationalism or rather some form of Christian law, perhaps based in scripture?? Unfortunately these have so often been a minority view in theological literature that it's almost laughable that Mr. Gage asserts that this was even the mainstream at any time in American history. Literally it is impossible to find a mainstream evangelical theologian or pastor advocating these views in the last 100 years.
Mr. Gage would like the evangelical church to find a new way to approach the public square. I would point Mr. Gage to the model offered by the National Association of Evangelicals and the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention. Both groups have offered a framework for public engagement.
Mr. Gage's strongest point is that America is losing its common frame of reference. This is absolutely true, the number of Americans who could hold to common ground and common ideas on a whole range of issues is rapidly declining. Virtues of decency, the common good, protecting the vulnerable, and prudence are short in supply in the public square, especially in Washington DC where Mr. Gage works. The church has an important role to play in being the place where those virtues are epitomized in all that we do.
The evangelical witness need not retool and rethink all things as Mr. Gage submits, but rather return to the old fashion virtues which we long ago argued for. The difference now is that we must invest and embody them in the way we act and uphold our prospective in the public square. In other words we need to regain and reaffirm our role as salt and light.
Apr 20, 2009
Battle Hymn of the Republic
I have seen Him in the watch-fires of a hundred circling camps,They have builded Him an altar in the evening dews and damps;I can read His righteous sentence by the dim and flaring lamps:His day is marching on.
I have read a fiery gospel writ in burnished rows of steel:"As ye deal with my contemners, so with you my grace shall deal;Let the Hero, born of woman, crush the serpent with his heel, Since God is marching on."
He has sounded forth the trumpet that shall never call retreat;He is sifting out the hearts of men before His judgment-seat:Oh, be swift, my soul, to answer Him! be jubilant, my feet!Our God is marching on.
In the beauty of the lilies Christ was born across the sea,With a glory in his bosom that transfigures you and me:As he died to make men holy, let us die to make men free,While God is marching on.
As part of our Christian duty let us obey and respect those who are put over us (Romans) and let us remember that our respect never takes the form of idolation.
Apr 16, 2009
The Crucified Jesus
N.T. Wright "What Saint Paul Really Said", Eerdmans, 1997, 47.
Feb 23, 2009
Wilberforce on Contemporary Christianity
"I hope you don't think I am being arrogant or overly harsh on cultural Christians. Look at the facts. Do cultural Christians view Christian faith as important enough to make it a priority when teaching their children what they believe and why they believe it? Or do they place greater emphasis on their children getting a good education than on learning about the things of God? Would they be embarrassed if their children did not possess the former while basically being indifferent about the latter? If their children have any understanding of Christian faith at all, they probably have acquired it on their own. If the children view themselves as Christians, it is probably not because they have studied the facts and come to a point of intellectual conviction but because their family is Christian, so they believe they must be Christians also.
The problem with this way of thinking is that authentic faith cannot be inherited. When Christianity is viewed in this way, intelligent and energetic young men and women will undoubtedly reach a point where they question the truth of Christianity and, when challenged, will abandon this 'inherited' faith that they cannot defend. They might begin to associate with peers who are unbelievers. In this company, they will find themselves unable to intelligently respond to objections to Christianity with which they are confronted. Had they really known what they believe and why they believe it, these kinds of encounters would not shake their faith one bit."